Joan of Arcadia

Amber Tamblyn

Joan Girardi

Joe Mantegna

Will Girardi

Mary Steenburgen

Helen Girardi

Jason Ritter

Kevin Girardi

Michael Welch

Luke Girardi

Christopher Rodriguez Marquette

Adam Rove

Becky Wahlstrom

Grace Polk

Aaron Himelstein

Friedman

Mageina Tovah

Glynis Figliola

Mark Totty

Det. Carlisle

Patrick Fabian

Gavin Price

Elaine Hendrix

Ms. Lischak

April Grace

Sergeant Toni Williams

Derek Morgan

Undersheriff Roy Roebuck

Annie Potts

Lieutenant Lucy Preston

Constance Zimmer

Sister Lilly Watters

Sprague Grayden

Judith Montgomery

Jeffrey Licon

Goth Kid God

David Burke

Father Ken Mallory

Kris Lemche

Cute Boy God

Juliette Goglia

Little Girl God

Sydney Tamiia Poitier

Rebecca Askew

Kathryn Joosten

Old Lady God

Misti Traya

Iris

Kimberly McCullough

Beth Reinhart

John Getz

D.A. Gabe Fellowes

👤

Barbara Evans

Jeanne

Riley Smith

Andy Baker

Erik Palladino

Lt. Michael Daghlian

👤

Catherine Petra Villalobos

Skater Girl (uncredited)

Morocco Omari

Principal Stephen Chadwick

Paul Sand

Rabbi Polonski

Mike Starr

Big Tough Guy God

👤

Mitch Longley

Barry 'The Bear' Caldwell

Diane Delano

Coach Carol Keady

Jack Plotnick

The Other Sammy

Sonya Eddy

Female Custodian God

Louis Mustillo

Garbage Man God

👤

Justin Scot

Officer Eicher

Russ Tamblyn

Dog Walker God

Trevor Einhorn

Mascot God

John Marshall Jones

Chess Player God

Patrick Breen

Sammy

Ivonne Coll

Marlene

Haylie Duff

Stevie Marx

David Dorfman

Rocky Tardio

Andrew Ableson

Andy Rees

👤

David Grammer

Carl Rove

👤

John Del Regno

Locksmith God

Jared Hillman

Brian Beaumont